FOR SOLVED PREVIOUS PAPERS OF INDIAN ECONOMIC SERVICE KINDLY CONTACT US ON OUR WHATSAPP NUMBER 9009368238
FOR SOLVED PREVIOUS PAPERS OF ISS KINDLY CONTACT US ON OUR WHATSAPP NUMBER 9009368238
FOR BOOK CATALOGUE
CLICK ON WHATSAPP CATALOGUE LINK https://wa.me/c/919009368238
Tradable Permits and Carbon Taxes: Market-Based Solutions for Climate Change
To combat climate change and reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, economists and policymakers have developed market-based instruments such as tradable permits (cap-and-trade systems) and carbon taxes. Both aim to put a price on carbon emissions, encouraging industries and individuals to adopt cleaner technologies and reduce their carbon footprint.
1. Tradable Permits (Cap-and-Trade Systems)
Tradable permits, also known as cap-and-trade systems, work by setting a limit (cap) on total emissions and allowing firms to trade emission permits in a market.
How It Works:
✔ Government sets a cap on total allowable emissions.
✔ Emission permits (allowances) are issued to firms, either for free or through an auction.
✔ Firms that emit less than their allocated quota can sell excess permits to other firms.
✔ Firms that exceed their quota must buy additional permits or reduce emissions.
Examples of Cap-and-Trade Programs:
- European Union Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) – The largest carbon market, covering sectors like energy and manufacturing.
- Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI, USA) – A cap-and-trade system for power plants in several U.S. states.
- China’s National Carbon Market (2021) – The world’s largest carbon trading system.
Advantages:
✔ Market efficiency – Companies that can reduce emissions cheaply do so and sell permits to others.
✔ Flexibility – Firms can choose whether to reduce emissions or buy allowances.
✔ Encourages innovation – Provides an economic incentive to develop cleaner technologies.
Challenges:
❌ Price volatility – If too many permits are issued, prices can drop, reducing incentives for emissions reduction.
❌ Implementation complexity – Requires strict monitoring and enforcement to prevent cheating.
2. Carbon Taxes
A carbon tax directly sets a price per ton of CO₂ emitted, encouraging businesses and consumers to cut emissions.
How It Works:
✔ The government sets a fixed price per ton of CO₂.
✔ Companies pay taxes based on their emissions.
✔ Higher carbon prices make fossil fuels more expensive, encouraging a shift to clean energy sources.
✔ Revenues from carbon taxes can be reinvested in renewable energy or returned to the public as rebates.
Examples of Carbon Taxes:
- Sweden (1991) – One of the world’s highest carbon taxes, leading to significant emissions reductions.
- Canada (2019) – A national carbon tax starting at $20 per ton and increasing annually.
- British Columbia, Canada (2008) – Revenue-neutral tax, where tax revenue is returned to citizens.
Advantages:
✔ Predictable costs – Unlike cap-and-trade, businesses know the exact cost of emissions.
✔ Simplicity – Easier to implement than cap-and-trade systems.
✔ Revenue generation – Governments can use carbon tax revenue to fund climate programs or offset costs for low-income households.
Challenges:
❌ Political resistance – Carbon taxes can be unpopular if they increase consumer costs.
❌ Regressive impact – Without compensation, they may disproportionately affect low-income households.
3. Comparison: Cap-and-Trade vs. Carbon Tax
| Feature | Tradable Permits (Cap-and-Trade) | Carbon Tax |
|---|---|---|
| Cost certainty | Uncertain (depends on market fluctuations) | Predictable tax per ton |
| Emission certainty | Cap ensures a fixed reduction in emissions | Uncertain (depends on how industries respond) |
| Market flexibility | Firms can trade permits | Fixed cost with no trading |
| Implementation difficulty | Complex (monitoring, enforcement) | Simpler to implement |
| Revenue generation | If permits are auctioned, it generates revenue | Generates revenue directly |
4. Which Policy is Better?
- Cap-and-trade is better for emission certainty but requires strict enforcement.
- Carbon taxes are simpler and provide price certainty but need careful design to avoid economic burdens.
- Some countries combine both for maximum impact.
Conclusion
Both tradable permits and carbon taxes are essential tools in climate policy. The effectiveness of each depends on how well they are designed and implemented. A global carbon pricing mechanism combining these approaches could be key to addressing climate change effectively.