FOR SOLVED PREVIOUS PAPERS OF INDIAN ECONOMIC SERVICE KINDLY CONTACT US ON OUR WHATSAPP NUMBER 9009368238
FOR SOLVED PREVIOUS PAPERS OF ISS KINDLY CONTACT US ON OUR WHATSAPP NUMBER 9009368238
FOR BOOK CATALOGUE
CLICK ON WHATSAPP CATALOGUE LINK https://wa.me/c/919009368238
Social Rate of Discount: Meaning & Importance
Introduction
The social rate of discount (SRD) is the rate used by governments and policymakers to evaluate public investment projects. It represents the present value of future benefits and costs to society, helping decide whether a project should be pursued.
Unlike private firms, which use market interest rates to discount future cash flows, governments consider social welfare, equity, and long-term sustainability when setting the SRD.
Why is the Social Rate of Discount Important?
The SRD plays a crucial role in public policy decisions, especially in projects with long-term impacts, such as:
✅ Infrastructure development (e.g., highways, railways, airports)
✅ Climate change mitigation (e.g., renewable energy projects, carbon reduction policies)
✅ Education & healthcare programs
✅ Social welfare initiatives
A lower discount rate gives more importance to future generations, while a higher discount rate prioritizes short-term gains.
Methods to Determine the Social Rate of Discount
There is no universally accepted SRD. However, economists use several approaches to estimate it:
1️⃣ Social Opportunity Cost of Capital (SOC) Approach
- Assumes that government funds come from private investments that yield a return.
- The SRD is set equal to the return on private sector investments.
- Often used in countries where capital markets are well-developed.
Example: If the private sector earns 5% return on investments, the government may set the SRD at 5%.
2️⃣ Social Time Preference Rate (STPR) Approach
- Based on how much society values present consumption over future consumption.
- Estimated using: STPR=ρ+ηgSTPR = \rho + \eta g Where:
- ρ (rho) = Pure rate of time preference (how impatient society is)
- η (eta) = Elasticity of marginal utility of consumption
- g = Growth rate of per capita consumption
Example: If society values future consumption highly, the STPR will be low, leading to a lower discount rate.
3️⃣ Shadow Price of Capital (SPC) Approach
- Considers the difference between the social value of investment and the private value.
- Adjusts the discount rate based on the opportunity cost of capital and economic distortions (taxes, subsidies, market failures).
Example: In developing countries, where capital is scarce, a higher SRD may be used to reflect the high opportunity cost of government borrowing.
Ramsey Rule (Prescriptive Approach)
- A theoretical method used by economists to derive an optimal discount rate: SRD=δ+ηgSRD = \delta + \eta g Where:
- δ (delta) = Pure time preference (how much we care about the future)
- η (eta) = Elasticity of marginal utility
- g = Growth rate of consumption
Example: If a country expects high future growth, it may use a higher discount rate.
What is the Optimal Social Discount Rate?
🔸 High vs. Low Discount Rates
🔺 High SRD (e.g., 6% or more) → Prioritizes short-term benefits, undervaluing future generations.
🔻 Low SRD (e.g., 1-3%) → Gives more weight to long-term benefits, favoring sustainability.
Most developed countries use lower SRDs (2-3%), while developing nations may use higher rates (5-8%) due to capital constraints.
Example:
- UK: Uses 3.5% for general projects and 1.5% for long-term projects (climate change).
- US: Uses 3% for regulatory analysis but sometimes 7% for private-sector comparisons.
- World Bank: Suggests 3-5% for social projects in developing economies.
Conclusion
The social rate of discount is a key tool in public investment decision-making, balancing current economic priorities with long-term societal well-being. Governments must choose wisely—too high a rate discourages sustainable projects, while too low a rate may lead to inefficient use of resources.
Key Takeaways:
✅ SRD helps governments evaluate long-term projects.
✅ Different methods (SOC, STPR, SPC, Ramsey) estimate SRD.
✅ Low SRD prioritizes future generations; high SRD prioritizes short-term gains.
✅ Countries set different SRDs based on economic conditions and policy goals.