FOR SOLVED PREVIOUS PAPERS OF INDIAN ECONOMIC SERVICE KINDLY CONTACT US ON OUR WHATSAPP NUMBER 9009368238
FOR SOLVED PREVIOUS PAPERS OF ISS KINDLY CONTACT US ON OUR WHATSAPP NUMBER 9009368238
FOR BOOK CATALOGUE
CLICK ON WHATSAPP CATALOGUE LINK https://wa.me/c/919009368238
Keynesian vs. Monetarist Schools of Thought
The Keynesian and Monetarist schools of thought are two of the most influential economic theories regarding macroeconomic policy, inflation, unemployment, and government intervention. While Keynesians emphasize government spending and fiscal policy, Monetarists focus on controlling the money supply to regulate the economy.
1. Introduction to Keynesian Economics
📌 Developed by John Maynard Keynes (1883–1946) during the Great Depression (1930s).
📌 Criticized Classical and Neo-Classical theories for failing to explain economic downturns.
📌 Advocates active government intervention to stabilize the economy.
Key Keynesian Concepts
1️⃣ Aggregate Demand Drives the Economy
- Economic output depends on total spending (aggregate demand).
- Government spending boosts demand, especially during recessions.
2️⃣ Recessions Are Caused by Low Demand
- During downturns, businesses cut production and jobs due to low demand.
- Unemployment rises, reducing incomes and further decreasing demand.
3️⃣ Government Must Intervene
- Fiscal policy (tax cuts, increased government spending) can stimulate demand.
- Monetary policy (lower interest rates) can encourage investment and consumption.
4️⃣ Multiplier Effect
- Government spending creates more income than the initial amount spent.
- Example: If the government builds a road, workers spend their wages, boosting demand in other sectors.
5️⃣ Sticky Wages and Prices
- Wages and prices don’t adjust quickly to changes in supply and demand.
- This causes prolonged unemployment during recessions.
🔹 Key Work: The General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money (1936)
2. Introduction to Monetarist Economics
📌 Developed by Milton Friedman (1912–2006) as a response to Keynesianism.
📌 Argues that money supply is the key driver of economic activity, not government spending.
📌 Supports minimal government intervention and a focus on monetary policy.
Key Monetarist Concepts
1️⃣ Money Supply Controls Inflation
- Too much money in circulation = inflation.
- Too little money = recession.
- The central bank (Federal Reserve, RBI, ECB) should regulate money growth.
2️⃣ Government Should Avoid Fiscal Stimulus
- Keynesian spending creates inflation without solving long-term problems.
- Government intervention distorts free markets.
3️⃣ Natural Rate of Unemployment
- Some unemployment is normal (due to job switching, technology changes).
- Government policies should not artificially lower unemployment.
4️⃣ Long-Run Effects of Monetary Policy
- In the short run, increasing money supply may boost growth.
- In the long run, it only causes inflation, not higher output.
5️⃣ Monetary Policy Over Fiscal Policy
- Central banks should control inflation by managing money supply, not through government spending.
🔹 Key Work: A Monetary History of the United States (1963)
3. Keynesian vs. Monetarist Economics: Key Differences
| Feature | Keynesian Economics | Monetarist Economics |
|---|---|---|
| Main Focus | Aggregate demand & government spending | Money supply & inflation control |
| Role of Government | Active intervention to stabilize economy | Minimal intervention (free markets work best) |
| Cause of Economic Fluctuations | Insufficient demand | Changes in money supply |
| Policy Preference | Fiscal policy (government spending, taxation) | Monetary policy (controlling money supply) |
| Inflation View | Caused by demand-pull factors | Caused by excessive money supply |
| Unemployment View | Can be reduced with stimulus | Exists naturally and should not be artificially lowered |
| Market Efficiency | Markets are inefficient and need intervention | Markets are efficient and self-correcting |
4. Keynesian vs. Monetarist Policies in Action
🔹 The Great Depression (1930s) & Keynesian Response
✔ The Great Depression saw high unemployment and a collapse in demand.
✔ Keynesians argued for increased government spending to boost demand and employment.
✔ This led to policies like Roosevelt’s New Deal in the U.S.
🔹 1970s Stagflation & Monetarist Response
✔ The 1970s saw high inflation + high unemployment (stagflation), which Keynesian policies failed to solve.
✔ Milton Friedman & Monetarists argued that excess money supply caused inflation.
✔ Central banks raised interest rates, reducing inflation but causing short-term recessions.
🔹 2008 Financial Crisis & Keynesian Revival
✔ The 2008 crisis led to mass unemployment and a financial collapse.
✔ Governments used Keynesian policies (stimulus packages, bailouts) to boost demand.
✔ Central banks lowered interest rates to encourage investment and spending.
5. Modern Relevance: Which Theory is More Effective?
💡 Keynesian Strengths
✔ Helps in economic crises (Great Depression, 2008 Crisis).
✔ Supports job creation and social welfare.
🚨 Keynesian Weaknesses
❌ Can lead to high government debt.
❌ Inflation risk if government overspends.
💡 Monetarist Strengths
✔ Focuses on long-term inflation control.
✔ Supports free markets and limited government intervention.
🚨 Monetarist Weaknesses
❌ Over-reliance on monetary policy may not work in deep recessions.
❌ Does not address income inequality or unemployment directly.
6. Conclusion
✔ Keynesians believe in government spending to stabilize demand and prevent unemployment.
✔ Monetarists argue that controlling the money supply is the best way to manage the economy.
✔ In reality, modern economies use a mix of both theories, balancing fiscal and monetary policies.