FOR SOLVED PREVIOUS PAPERS OF INDIAN ECONOMIC SERVICE KINDLY CONTACT US ON OUR WHATSAPP NUMBER 9009368238
FOR SOLVED PREVIOUS PAPERS OF ISS KINDLY CONTACT US ON OUR WHATSAPP NUMBER 9009368238
FOR BOOK CATALOGUE
CLICK ON WHATSAPP CATALOGUE LINK https://wa.me/c/919009368238
Dependency Theory: The Views of Samir Amin and Andre Gunder Frank
The Dependency School, led by economists like Samir Amin and Andre Gunder Frank, challenges traditional economic theories that assume poor nations can develop by following the same path as rich nations. Instead, they argue that global capitalism systematically keeps developing nations dependent on and exploited by richer countries.
This blog explores their views on why underdevelopment persists, their perspectives on the role of the state and the market, and how developing countries can break free from economic dependency.
1️⃣ Understanding Dependency Theory
Dependency theorists argue that the world economy is divided into:
- Core Countries (Developed Nations): Industrialized economies like the US, UK, and Germany that dominate global trade and finance.
- Periphery Countries (Developing Nations): Former colonies in Africa, Latin America, and Asia that provide raw materials and cheap labor but remain underdeveloped.
- Semi-Periphery Countries: Emerging economies (like Brazil, India, and China) that are partially industrialized but still dependent on richer nations.
🔹 The Core-Periphery Relationship
- The core countries extract cheap resources and labor from the periphery.
- The periphery remains dependent on the core for technology, investment, and finished goods.
- This unequal relationship blocks independent development and keeps developing countries poor.
Now, let’s look at how Samir Amin and Andre Gunder Frank developed these ideas further.
2️⃣ Samir Amin: Delinking from the Global System
Samir Amin (1931–2018) believed that underdevelopment is not a stage before development, but a direct result of global capitalism. He argued that:
📌 Key Idea: “Accumulation on a World Scale”
- The wealth of rich nations is built on the exploitation of the periphery.
- Capitalism promotes unequal trade, where developing countries export raw materials at low prices and import manufactured goods at high prices.
- This process prevents industrialization in the periphery.
📌 Role of the State vs. the Market
- The free market is a tool of the core countries to exploit developing nations.
- The state must play a strong role in development by:
- Nationalizing key industries (like mining, oil, and agriculture).
- Investing in domestic production rather than relying on imports.
- Limiting foreign control over the economy.
📌 Amin’s Solution: “Delinking”
- Developing countries should break away (“delink”) from the global economic system and focus on self-sufficiency.
- Instead of exporting raw materials, they should develop local industries and focus on regional cooperation.
- Example: China’s early economic strategy of state-led industrialization aligns with Amin’s ideas.
3️⃣ Andre Gunder Frank: Development of Underdevelopment
Andre Gunder Frank (1929–2005) went even further, stating that the periphery is underdeveloped precisely because it is integrated into the world economy.
📌 Key Idea: “Development of Underdevelopment”
- Underdevelopment is not a natural stage, but an active process created by global capitalism.
- Even when developing countries grow, the benefits go to foreign investors and local elites, not the majority of people.
- Example: In Latin America, foreign corporations extract profits, while local workers remain poor.
📌 Role of the State vs. the Market
- The market alone cannot lead to real development because it is controlled by global powers.
- The state should:
- Reduce dependency on Western economies by promoting local industries.
- Protect domestic markets from foreign competition.
- Encourage land reforms and redistribution of wealth to reduce inequality.
📌 Frank’s Solution: Revolution and Socialism
- Since capitalism creates underdevelopment, socialist policies (like those in Cuba or China) are necessary for real progress.
- He supported strong state intervention and breaking ties with global financial institutions like the IMF and World Bank.
4️⃣ Comparing Amin and Frank’s Views
| Feature | Samir Amin | Andre Gunder Frank |
|---|---|---|
| Cause of Underdevelopment | Exploitation by the global capitalist system | Integration into the global economy itself |
| Solution | Delinking (self-reliance and national development) | Socialism & Revolution (breaking ties with capitalism) |
| Role of the Market | Markets reinforce dependency | Markets serve the interests of the rich |
| Role of the State | Strong state control is needed | The state should lead a socialist transformation |
| Example | China’s self-sufficiency model | Cuba’s socialist economy |
5️⃣ Are These Ideas Still Relevant Today?
✔ Yes! Many developing countries still struggle with debt, trade dependency, and foreign investment control.
✔ Globalization has deepened dependency → Tech giants and multinational corporations now control many economies.
✔ China, India, and Brazil have shown that strategic state intervention works → These countries grew by protecting domestic industries before opening up.
📌 Modern Takeaways:
- 100% delinking is unrealistic, but developing countries can diversify trade partners and strengthen domestic production.
- Debt traps from IMF & World Bank loans show that dependency is still a major issue.
- State intervention is necessary in key sectors like health, education, and infrastructure to ensure sustainable growth.
6️⃣ Conclusion: How Can Developing Countries Break Free?
🌍 A balanced approach is needed! Instead of complete isolation (delinking) or total dependence on the market, developing nations should:
✅ Diversify their economies → Invest in technology and high-value industries.
✅ Strengthen regional trade → Reduce reliance on Western economies.
✅ Limit foreign control over key sectors → Regulate multinational corporations.
✅ Use state policies strategically → Invest in education, infrastructure, and industrialization.