FOR SOLVED PREVIOUS PAPERS OF INDIAN ECONOMIC SERVICE KINDLY CONTACT US ON OUR WHATSAPP NUMBER 9009368238
FOR SOLVED PREVIOUS PAPERS OF ISS KINDLY CONTACT US ON OUR WHATSAPP NUMBER 9009368238
FOR BOOK CATALOGUE
CLICK ON WHATSAPP CATALOGUE LINK https://wa.me/c/919009368238
Mercantilism and Physiocrats
1. Introduction
📌 Mercantilism and Physiocracy were two of the earliest economic schools of thought before classical economics emerged.
📌 Mercantilism (16th-18th century) emphasized state control, trade surplus, and accumulation of wealth through gold and silver.
📌 Physiocrats (18th century, France) believed that land and agriculture were the true sources of wealth, opposing the restrictive policies of mercantilism.
Why are these theories important?
✔ They shaped modern economic policies and influenced Adam Smith’s classical economics.
✔ They laid the foundation for debates on government intervention vs. free markets.
2. Mercantilism (1500s–1700s)
🔹 Key Idea:
✔ Wealth is measured by gold and silver reserves, and a nation should maximize exports while minimizing imports.
✔ Strong government intervention is necessary to control trade and industry.
🔹 Main Features of Mercantilism
1️⃣ Trade Surplus (Exports > Imports)
- Nations should sell more goods to other countries than they buy to accumulate wealth.
2️⃣ Colonial Expansion
- Colonies provided raw materials to the mother country and bought finished goods, ensuring a trade advantage.
3️⃣ Government Control and Protectionism
- High tariffs on imports to protect domestic industries.
- Monopolies granted by the state to control trade and production.
4️⃣ Bullionism (Gold & Silver Accumulation)
- The more gold and silver a country had, the wealthier it was considered.
5️⃣ State-Supported Industries
- Governments subsidized industries that promoted self-sufficiency and increased exports.
🔹 Famous Mercantilist Thinkers
✔ Jean-Baptiste Colbert (France) → Developed France’s state-controlled economy under King Louis XIV.
✔ Thomas Mun (England) → Wrote England’s Treasure by Foreign Trade, advocating for a favorable balance of trade.
✔ Antonio Serra (Italy) → Studied how trade policies affect economic prosperity.
🔹 Criticism of Mercantilism
🚨 Why did it decline? 🚨
1️⃣ Ignored Individual Freedom → Heavy state control limited economic competition.
2️⃣ Inefficient Trade Restrictions → High tariffs made goods more expensive.
3️⃣ Gold & Silver ≠ Real Wealth → Adam Smith argued that real wealth is based on production and trade, not just money reserves.
4️⃣ Led to Conflicts & Wars → Countries fought over colonies and trade routes (e.g., British-French wars).
💡 Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations (1776) directly opposed mercantilism, advocating for free markets instead.
3. Physiocrats (1700s – France)
📌 Physiocracy emerged in 18th-century France, opposing mercantilist policies and advocating for a natural economic order based on agriculture.
🔹 Key Idea:
✔ Land and agriculture are the only true sources of wealth.
✔ Minimal government intervention—the economy should follow natural laws (e.g., supply and demand).
🔹 Main Features of Physiocracy
1️⃣ Agriculture as the Primary Source of Wealth
- Unlike mercantilists, Physiocrats believed manufacturing and trade do not create wealth; only farming does.
2️⃣ Laissez-Faire (Minimal Government Intervention)
- The economy should run without government interference—only protect property rights and enforce laws.
3️⃣ Natural Economic Order
- The economy follows natural laws, just like physics and biology.
- Markets self-regulate if left alone.
4️⃣ Single Tax Theory
- Tax only landowners, since land generates wealth.
5️⃣ Opposition to Mercantilism
- Criticized trade restrictions, monopolies, and government interference.
🔹 Famous Physiocrats
✔ François Quesnay (1694–1774) → Founder of Physiocracy.
- Wrote Tableau Économique (1758), one of the first economic models, showing how wealth circulates in an economy.
✔ Anne-Robert Turgot (1727–1781) → Advocated free trade and tax reforms in France.
✔ Pierre Samuel du Pont de Nemours → Helped spread Physiocratic ideas in the U.S.
🔹 Criticism of Physiocracy
🚨 Why did it decline? 🚨
1️⃣ Overemphasis on Agriculture → Ignored the role of industry and trade in wealth creation.
2️⃣ Simplistic Economic Model → The economy is more complex than just land-based production.
3️⃣ Failed in Policy Implementation → France’s government ignored many Physiocratic reforms.
💡 Despite its limitations, Physiocracy influenced Adam Smith’s free-market ideas and modern economics.
4. Mercantilism vs. Physiocracy: A Comparison
| Feature | Mercantilism | Physiocracy |
|---|---|---|
| Main Idea | Wealth = Gold & Silver | Wealth = Agriculture |
| Government Role | Strong control over trade & economy | Minimal intervention (Laissez-faire) |
| Source of Wealth | Trade, industry, and colonies | Land & farming |
| Trade Policy | Protectionist (high tariffs, monopolies) | Free trade |
| Tax Policy | Many taxes on goods & businesses | Single land tax |
| Famous Thinkers | Jean-Baptiste Colbert, Thomas Mun | François Quesnay, Turgot |
5. Legacy and Influence
🔹 Mercantilism’s Influence Today:
✔ Protectionist policies still exist (tariffs, subsidies, and trade wars).
✔ Countries still focus on export-driven growth (e.g., China, Germany).
🔹 Physiocracy’s Influence Today:
✔ Ideas of free markets and minimal government intervention influenced Adam Smith and modern capitalism.
✔ Land tax theories inspired later economists like Henry George.
6. Conclusion
✔ Mercantilism promoted state-controlled economies and trade monopolies, leading to colonialism and economic nationalism.
✔ Physiocrats opposed mercantilism, advocating free trade and agriculture as the main source of wealth.
✔ Both schools shaped modern economic policies, influencing debates on government intervention vs. free markets.