FOR SOLVED PREVIOUS PAPERS OF INDIAN ECONOMIC SERVICE KINDLY CONTACT US ON OUR WHATSAPP NUMBER 9009368238
FOR SOLVED PREVIOUS PAPERS OF ISS KINDLY CONTACT US ON OUR WHATSAPP NUMBER 9009368238
FOR BOOK CATALOGUE
CLICK ON WHATSAPP CATALOGUE LINK https://wa.me/c/919009368238
Social Choice Theory and Other Recent Schools of Thought
1. Introduction
Social choice theory is a branch of economics and political science that studies how societies make collective decisions based on individual preferences. It addresses how to aggregate individual choices into a fair and efficient social decision. The field gained prominence with the work of Kenneth Arrow, Amartya Sen, and other economists.
Apart from social choice theory, recent schools of economic thought have emerged to address new economic challenges, including behavioral economics, complexity economics, and new institutional economics.
2. Social Choice Theory
🔹 (1) What is Social Choice Theory?
✔ Social choice theory examines how to derive a collective decision from individual preferences.
✔ It focuses on voting, fairness, welfare economics, and group decision-making.
✔ Kenneth Arrow’s Impossibility Theorem shows that no voting system can perfectly satisfy all fairness criteria.
🔹 (2) Arrow’s Impossibility Theorem
Kenneth Arrow’s theorem states that no voting system can simultaneously satisfy the following fairness conditions:
✔ Unrestricted domain – The system must work for all possible individual preferences.
✔ Non-dictatorship – No single person should decide for everyone.
✔ Pareto efficiency – If all individuals prefer option A over B, society should also prefer A over B.
✔ Independence of irrelevant alternatives – The ranking between two options should not be affected by a third irrelevant choice.
📌 Example:
- In elections, ranked-choice voting may sometimes lead to paradoxical results (e.g., a candidate winning despite being disliked by the majority).
✔ Implication: Perfectly fair collective decision-making is impossible under Arrow’s criteria.
🔹 (3) Amartya Sen’s Contributions to Social Choice Theory
✔ Sen expanded Arrow’s work to focus on welfare economics, inequality, and human capabilities.
✔ Capabilities Approach – Economic policies should enhance people’s freedoms and quality of life, not just GDP growth.
✔ Example: Measuring development through education, health, and freedoms, not just income.
3. Other Recent Schools of Thought in Economics
🔹 (1) Behavioral Economics
✔ Challenges the traditional assumption that humans are perfectly rational.
✔ Introduces concepts like bounded rationality, heuristics, and cognitive biases.
✔ Key Contributors: Daniel Kahneman, Richard Thaler.
📌 Example:
- People overvalue losses compared to gains (loss aversion), which affects investment decisions.
✔ Policy Implications:
- Governments use “nudge theory” (e.g., automatic enrollment in retirement savings) to encourage better choices.
🔹 (2) Complexity Economics
✔ Traditional economics assumes equilibrium, but complexity economics studies how economies evolve dynamically.
✔ Uses network theory, agent-based modeling, and emergent behavior.
✔ Key Contributors: Brian Arthur, Santa Fe Institute.
📌 Example:
- Financial crises are not always predictable using standard models but can be understood through network interactions and feedback loops.
✔ Policy Implications:
- Regulations should adapt to uncertainty, considering how markets evolve over time.
🔹 (3) New Institutional Economics (NIE)
✔ Studies how institutions (laws, norms, property rights) shape economic behavior.
✔ Highlights the role of transaction costs, contracts, and governance.
✔ Key Contributors: Douglass North, Oliver Williamson.
📌 Example:
- Countries with strong legal institutions (property rights, contract enforcement) grow faster than those with weak institutions.
✔ Policy Implications:
- Reforming legal frameworks and reducing corruption can improve economic performance.
🔹 (4) Post-Keynesian Economics
✔ Extends Keynesian economics, emphasizing uncertainty, distribution, and demand-driven growth.
✔ Challenges mainstream macroeconomics by focusing on financial instability and income inequality.
✔ Key Contributors: Joan Robinson, Hyman Minsky.
📌 Example:
- Minsky’s Financial Instability Hypothesis explains how speculative lending cycles cause financial crises.
✔ Policy Implications:
- Stronger financial regulations can prevent banking crises.
4. Conclusion
✔ Social choice theory studies how societies make collective decisions but faces limitations (Arrow’s Theorem).
✔ Recent schools of thought like behavioral economics, complexity economics, and new institutional economics offer new insights into human behavior, financial crises, and governance.
✔ Modern economics integrates multiple approaches to understand today’s complex economic challenges.